Is science built on the shoulders of women? : a study of gender differences in contributorship


Article
Version acceptée / Accepted Manuscript

Date de publication

Identifiant ORCID de l’auteur

Contributrices et contributeurs

Direction de recherche

Publié dans

Academic medicine
Academic medicine

Date de la Conférence

Lieu de la Conférence

Éditeur

Lippincott, Williams & Wilkins

Cycle d'études

Programme

Organisme subventionnaire

Résumé

Purpose: Women remain underrepresented in the production of scientific literature and relatively little is known regarding the labor roles played by women in the production of knowledge. This research examines these labor roles, using contributorship data from science and medical journals published by the Public Library of Science (PLOS). PLOS journals require each author to indicate their contribution to one or more of the following tasks: (1) Analyzed the data; (2) Conceived and designed the experiments; (3) Contributes reagents/materials/analysis tools; (4) Performed the experiments; and (5) Wrote the paper. Method: We analyzed contribution data from more than 85,000 articles published between 2008 and 2013 in PLOS journals with respect to gender using both descriptive and regression analyses. Results: Gender is a significant variable in determining the likelihood of performing a certain task associated with authorship. Women are significantly more likely to be associated with performing experiments and men are more likely to be associated with all other authorship roles. This holds true controlling for age: although experimentation is associated with academically younger scholars, the gap between male and female contribution to this task remains constant across academic age. Inequalities are observed in the distribution of scientific labor roles. Conclusions: These disparities have implications for the production of science, the evaluation of scholars, and the ethical conduct of science. Adopting the practice of identifying contributorship rather than authorship in scientific journal will allow for greater transparency, accountability, and equitable allocation of resources in science.

Table des matières

Notes

Notes

Autre version linguistique

Ensemble de données lié

Licence

Approbation

Évaluation

Complété par

Référencé par

Ce document diffusé sur Papyrus est la propriété exclusive des titulaires des droits d'auteur et est protégé par la Loi sur le droit d'auteur (L.R.C. (1985), ch. C-42). Sauf si le document est diffusé sous une licence Creative Commons, il ne peut être utilisé que dans le cadre d'une utilisation équitable et non commerciale comme le prévoit la Loi (i.e. à des fins d'étude privée ou de recherche, de critique ou de compte-rendu). Pour toute autre utilisation, une autorisation écrite des titulaires des droits d'auteur sera nécessaire.